A CONSIDERATION : ISLAM = BUDDHA? (4)
Muhammad in Buddha Scriptures
(Continuation from 10/ 17 / 2006)
3. The aspect of the loyal disciples.
Followed to the book of Secred Books of the East, Volume 2, and page 36, Maha Parinibbana Sutta Chapter 5: 36 has been said, “In one of Gautama Buddha preach, he had told to his disciples that all the past Buddha poses their own disciples and servants who so loyal to them. The students who were very loyal to me for now is Ananda. Then, the next Buddha that will exist will posses disciples and servant who very loyal to them".
A contradiction: The prophet of Muhammad too posses one student and servant that very loyal to him; Anas bin Malik r.a. that gift by his parent to Rasullullah s.a.w. when he is in 8 years old. The prophet very loves to him and accepted him as his own child. Anas always be beside the Prophet no matter in comfort time or war even in the death time of Rasulullah s.a.w. Anas still beside hum. This event as example the loyalty of Anas to Rasulullah:
§ In Uhud War (625 AD) when the prophet closed to be killed, Anas still beside him, in that time, Anas was only a child that in 11 years old.
§ Hunain War (630 AD) the prophet of Muhammad s.a.w. had been besieged by his enemy that consists the archers, Anas still with Rasulullah s.a.w. and for that time he is the teenage with age in 16 years old.
Here have been proven that have a similarity between Anas and Ananda. In the times of Buddha was attacked by the mad elephant, Ananda still with Buddha and he not run away.
(Continuation from 10/ 17 / 2006)
3. The aspect of the loyal disciples.
Followed to the book of Secred Books of the East, Volume 2, and page 36, Maha Parinibbana Sutta Chapter 5: 36 has been said, “In one of Gautama Buddha preach, he had told to his disciples that all the past Buddha poses their own disciples and servants who so loyal to them. The students who were very loyal to me for now is Ananda. Then, the next Buddha that will exist will posses disciples and servant who very loyal to them".
A contradiction: The prophet of Muhammad too posses one student and servant that very loyal to him; Anas bin Malik r.a. that gift by his parent to Rasullullah s.a.w. when he is in 8 years old. The prophet very loves to him and accepted him as his own child. Anas always be beside the Prophet no matter in comfort time or war even in the death time of Rasulullah s.a.w. Anas still beside hum. This event as example the loyalty of Anas to Rasulullah:
§ In Uhud War (625 AD) when the prophet closed to be killed, Anas still beside him, in that time, Anas was only a child that in 11 years old.
§ Hunain War (630 AD) the prophet of Muhammad s.a.w. had been besieged by his enemy that consists the archers, Anas still with Rasulullah s.a.w. and for that time he is the teenage with age in 16 years old.
Here have been proven that have a similarity between Anas and Ananda. In the times of Buddha was attacked by the mad elephant, Ananda still with Buddha and he not run away.
posted by Dr. Nawi at 10:59 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home